Financial literacy · Accounting · Case study
Dev does the books
Fourteen pairs of sneakers, $350 in his head, and what the numbers actually said.
Dev is 17 and runs a sneaker cleaning hustle from his garage. He charges $25 a pair, and word has spread through school: deep clean, sole whitening, laces washed, photos before and after. Last month he cleaned 14 pairs, so he tells his mates he made $350. It sounds right. Fourteen times twenty five. Then his aunt, an accountant, asks one quiet question over dinner: made $350, or collected $350, or cleared $350? Dev realises he does not know the difference. That weekend, they do the books.
They start with income. Fourteen pairs went through the garage, but one was his cousin's, cleaned for free as a favour. So only 13 pairs earned anything: 13 times $25 is $325, not $350. Then his aunt asks who has actually paid. Dev checks his transfers. One customer, two pairs, $50, keeps saying he will fix him up next week. So Dev has earned $325 this month, but only $275 of it has landed. The $50 is real, his aunt says, but it is a different kind of real: money owed to you, an asset to track and to chase, not cash to spend.
Now the money going out. Dev pulls up his statement and finds $68 spent this month on cleaner, brushes and whitening solution: supplies used up doing the work, a clear expense. He also spent $40 boosting posts on Instagram, which brought in, as best he can tell, three new customers. Also an expense. Then the big one: a $210 drying rack, bought at the start of the month. Dev wants to call it an expense too, but his aunt stops him. The rack is not used up. It will stand in that garage drying sneakers for years. It is equipment, an asset he owns, a swap of cash for a thing of value. If he wants to be precise he can count a small slice of its cost against each month of its life, but it does not belong as a $210 hit against one month's work.
One more thing turns up while they dig: the supply shop let Dev take a bulk order of cleaner a while back and pay it off, and $75 of that tab is still owing. It has not touched this month's expenses, but it is a debt, and the books have to show it.
His aunt draws the profit and loss for the month on the back of an envelope. Income earned: $325. Expenses: supplies $68 plus advertising $40, total $108. Profit: $217. Dev stares at it. In his head he made $350. On paper, the hustle cleared $217, and only $167 of that is currently sitting in his account as new cash once the unpaid $50 is set aside. Not bad money for a month of weekends, his aunt says. But $133 a month less than the story you were telling.
The cash side matters as much as the profit, his aunt adds, because they are not the same pile. Dev earned $217 in profit, but $50 of the income behind it has not arrived, so the new cash the month actually put in his account is $167, not $217. That is still a healthy month. But if he had gone and spent as though the full $217 were sitting there ready to go, he would have come up short, which is the exact trap that catches real businesses when they treat a good profit as money already in hand.
Then the photo: a tiny balance sheet. Assets: $245 cash in his hustle account, $50 owed by the slow paying customer, and the drying rack at $210. That is $505 of assets. Liabilities: the $75 still owed to the supply shop. What the hustle is worth to Dev, its equity: $430. Two reports, one envelope, and for the first time Dev can see the whole machine at once.
The drying rack gives Dev his first taste of depreciation, the word for spreading a long lasting cost over its life. Suppose the rack lasts three years of weekend cleaning. Rather than one brutal $210 hit in the month he bought it, a fairer picture charges a small slice against each month it serves, something like $6 a month across those three years. Illustrative numbers, but they show the point: lumping the whole cost into one month would have made that month look like a loss and every month after it look better than it really was. The rack earns for years, so its cost belongs across those years.
The numbers start talking almost immediately. The free clean for his cousin cost real supplies and a Saturday hour: favours are fine, but they belong in the books as a choice, not a blur. The $40 of ads brought three customers worth $75, decent, but worth testing against a month of free posting before it becomes a habit. At $25 a pair, each clean carries about $8 of costs, and mates rates would eat the margin fast, so the price probably rises to $30 for the fiddly jobs. And the $50: Dev sends the message that night, polite and specific. Doing the books took one afternoon. Every decision that month got sharper because of it.
Your tasks
Work through these in order, on paper or in a doc. They are the point of the story.
- 1Rebuild Dev's profit and loss for the month from the story: income earned, each expense, and the profit. Show why the answer is $217 and not $350.
- 2Explain why the $210 drying rack is not an expense of this month, and what kind of thing it is instead. What would a fairer way of counting its cost look like?
- 3Dev earned $325 but only $275 arrived. Explain the difference between earning income and receiving cash, and where the missing $50 lives in his books.
- 4Rebuild Dev's balance sheet: list each asset with its value, the liability, and calculate the equity of $430. Then explain what happens to the balance sheet on the day the slow customer finally pays.
- 5Using the numbers, argue for one change Dev should make next month: raise the price, cut or keep the ad spend, or something else. Defend your choice with figures from the story, not feelings.
- 6Dev's profit was $217 but only $167 of new cash reached his account. Explain the difference in your own words, and say what could go wrong next month if he budgeted as though he had the full $217 to spend.
- 7Dev's hustle is growing. Using the hobby versus business idea from the business lesson, argue whether Dev is running a hobby or a business yet, and list what would change for his record keeping and tax if it clearly became a business.
- 8Now run the whole exercise on a hustle of your own choosing, real or planned: babysitting, tutoring, reselling, lawns, anything. Invent honest numbers for one month, then build the profit and loss and the tiny balance sheet, including at least one asset that is not cash and one amount owed in either direction.